Welcome to a special recap and deep dive into the latest episode of The Flip Side: Get Your Teach On podcast, featuring Naomi O'Brien, an experienced educator, literacy advocate, and creator of Read Like a Rockstar Teaching. Since beginning her education career in 2010, Naomi has been passionate about reading, high expectations, and making sure every student receives the challenging education they deserve.
In this episode, Naomi shares a powerful reminder from Susan Winebrenner: “It is inequitable to prevent students from receiving an appropriately challenging education until other students get their learning needs met.”
From challenging gifted learners to scaffolding instruction, rethinking differentiation, and holding high expectations for every student, her message is clear: Equity isn't about making sure everyone does the same thing. It's about making sure every student has access to meaningful learning and opportunities to grow.
Let's break down the biggest takeaways and practical strategies from this inspiring conversation.
Good Instruction Isn't a Personality Trait: Be Yourself and Get Results
Main Takeaway:
There isn't one personality type or teaching style that guarantees success in the classroom. Effective teaching is about implementing strong instructional practices and creating systems that help students succeed, not trying to become someone you're not.
Naomi's Perspective:
During the Get Your Teach On conference, Naomi and the host had the opportunity to teach model lessons with completely different personalities and approaches.
While one teacher brought big energy, loud call-and-response strategies, and an enthusiastic presence, Naomi demonstrated a quieter, more understated approach.
What they discovered was that both teaching styles could produce the same results.
Naomi explains that effective instruction is a combination of strong practices and the art of teaching. You can deliver those practices in a way that feels authentic to your personality.
She also points out that classroom routines and expectations matter. Because students had already practiced certain attention-getting strategies during an earlier lesson, Naomi didn't need to reteach those expectations. She could simply use the systems already established.
Actionable Advice:
Embrace Your Personality: Stop comparing your teaching style to the educator next door.
Focus on Best Practices: Prioritize effective instruction over trying to create a particular classroom persona.
Establish Systems: Teach students clear routines and expectations so they know what to do.
Measure What Matters: Focus on student engagement, learning, and results rather than how your teaching looks to others.
Expert Insight:
You can be loud, quiet, energetic, or calm. What matters is that your instructional choices are intentional and effective. Good teaching isn't about having a certain personality; it's about creating the conditions for students to succeed.
Teach to the Top: Raise the Expectations for Everyone
Main Takeaway:
Students who are already performing above grade level deserve meaningful opportunities to grow, too. Equity means ensuring that every student receives an appropriately challenging education, not focusing exclusively on students who are struggling.
Naomi's Approach:
Naomi shares how her perspective on instruction changed when she began intentionally planning lessons with her highest-achieving students in mind.
Instead of planning for the middle and then trying to differentiate up and down, she began planning one challenging lesson and scaffolding as needed so every student could access the learning.
She discovered that strategies designed to challenge advanced learners often improved instruction for everyone.
By asking higher-level questions and increasing cognitive demand, she saw students across achievement levels rise to the occasion.
Naomi also shares her perspective as a parent of a gifted child. She remembers her son coming home from kindergarten after counting to 20 and asking, "Do you think my teacher knows that I know how to count to 1,000?"
His experience highlights something important: Advanced learners want to feel seen, recognized, and challenged just as much as any other student.
Actionable Advice:
Plan for Your Highest Learners: Consider what would challenge your most advanced students before planning how to scaffold the lesson.
Raise the Quality of Questions: Incorporate higher-level thinking and more complex questions for everyone.
Scaffold as Needed: Provide support and access points so all students can work toward challenging learning goals.
Recognize Every Learner: Don't assume students who are performing well no longer need your attention.
Celebrate Growth: Give students opportunities to stretch their thinking and demonstrate what they're capable of doing.
Expert Insight:
When you raise the level of thinking in your classroom, you aren't leaving struggling students behind. You're creating opportunities for everyone to grow. Planning for higher expectations and scaffolding appropriately can raise the quality of education for all learners.
Stop Making Your Highest Students the Classroom Helpers
Main Takeaway:
Fast finishers and advanced learners shouldn't automatically become teacher assistants, tutors, or students who are sent to an iPad when they complete their work. They deserve instruction that continues to challenge and develop their skills.
Naomi's Teaching Strategy:
Naomi explains that asking advanced students to help their classmates might seem like a productive solution. After all, they're reviewing content while helping someone else learn.
But constantly assigning these students the role of teacher helper doesn't necessarily provide the academic growth they need.
Instead, Naomi encourages educators to anticipate their needs and prepare meaningful enrichment opportunities.
One simple strategy is to use Bloom's Taxonomy. Rather than creating an entirely different assignment, move up a level in the type of thinking you're asking students to do.
She also shares an example from her classroom where she grouped students using fun names like burgers, fries, and carrots. The carrot group represented students who needed additional challenges.
When planning math questions, Naomi would include an additional challenge specifically for that group. Other students could attempt it, too, but her advanced learners knew she had intentionally planned something just for them.
Actionable Advice:
Ditch the Busywork: Avoid automatically assigning advanced students extra worksheets, tutoring responsibilities, or independent screen time.
Use Bloom's Taxonomy: Increase the cognitive demand by changing the verb in your learning objective or question.
Anticipate Student Needs: Prepare enrichment activities before students finish their regular assignments.
Keep the Same Learning Target: Challenge students to think more deeply about the content you're already teaching.
Consider Cluster Grouping: When appropriate, group advanced learners together so teachers can plan meaningful enrichment opportunities for the group.
Expert Insight:
Differentiation doesn't have to mean creating three completely different lessons. Sometimes, changing the level of thinking required is enough to provide students with a meaningful challenge.
Hold High Expectations: Don't Lower the Bar
Main Takeaway:
When students struggle to meet academic expectations, lowering the standards shouldn't automatically be the solution. Instead, educators should examine their instructional practices and consider what they can do differently to help students succeed.
Naomi's Perspective:
Naomi challenges the idea that making standards less rigorous will automatically improve student outcomes.
She explains that even when expectations are lowered, students don't necessarily meet them. Instead of continually reducing the level of challenge, educators need to focus on effective instructional practices that help students reach those expectations.
She also highlights how education has evolved through research, new resources, and a better understanding of how children learn.
Just as professionals in other fields are expected to stay informed about research and advances in their work, educators should be willing to examine current evidence and put effective practices into action.
Actionable Advice:
Maintain High Expectations: Believe that students are capable of more than we sometimes give them credit for.
Reflect on Instruction: When students struggle, ask what you could teach differently or more effectively.
Use Research: Stay informed about evidence-based instructional practices and apply what you learn.
Provide Access Points: Break down challenging learning into manageable steps without removing the rigor.
Focus on Growth: Don't confuse providing support with lowering expectations.
Expert Insight:
When students don't meet a learning goal, it's worth examining our own instructional practices before assuming the expectations were too high. The goal isn't to make learning easier by lowering the bar. It's to give students the tools and support they need to reach it.
Your Challenge This Week: Teach to the Top!
This week, try one simple shift in your classroom to provide more meaningful challenges for every learner:
Think about your highest-achieving student and plan one question that would genuinely challenge them.
Take an existing lesson and increase the cognitive demand by changing the verb in your learning objective.
Replace a fast-finisher activity with an enrichment opportunity connected to your current learning target.
Ask a higher-level question and give every student the opportunity to attempt it.
Identify one instructional practice you could adjust to help students access more challenging content.
You don't need to create three separate lesson plans or spend hours preparing complicated enrichment activities. Start by raising the level of thinking in your classroom and providing the scaffolds students need to access it.
Remember, advanced learners deserve to grow just as much as students who are working toward grade-level expectations. Every student comes to school to learn, and every student deserves to be challenged.
As Naomi O'Brien reminds us, it is inequitable to prevent students from receiving an appropriately challenging education while waiting for everyone else's needs to be met.
Don't teach only to the middle. Don't assume your highest students are fine. Plan with every learner in mind, raise the level of instruction, and scaffold as needed.
For more literacy resources, teaching strategies, and classroom inspiration, follow Naomi O'Brien on Instagram at @readlikearockstarteaching and visit https://readlikearockstarteaching.com/
Subscribe to The Flip Side: Get Your Teach On podcast for new episodes every Monday, featuring fresh perspectives, practical strategies, and motivation to help you make an impact in your classroom.
Take one idea back to your classroom this week, challenge your highest learners, and remember: When we raise the level of learning for some, we can raise the level of learning for everyone!